The Garage Cafe

Reviews

• Rosa T.

  star star star star star 2 June 2026

  OMG, the best customized to order Sandwiches in Birmingham.
  This place took us some time to find and eventually found it, hence the label "Hidden Gem" in Birmingham. There was so much hype about the place, that my friends and I decided to go. Since we went during lunch hour we weren't able to order from the bar (oh well), but the bartender was so nice and helpful. He let us know where we needed to order for the lunch menu.
  At first, I thought I was going to order from a list of signature sandwiches, but it's more of built your own sandwich (BYOS). I had a heated turkey meat with pepper jack cheese on wheat bread with most of the condiments from the topping list. I did not expect for a sandwich to be so freaking delicious, and I have had my share of sandwiches. I received chips and a pickle with my order for the low price of $8.25.. (what a great deal) Also, this place only takes cash, so make sure you have cash, if not they do have an ATM on site.
  
  This is the ideal place to get you sandwich fix on with a nice drink to wash it down with.
  
  I will be back!!!

• Gabe P.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  I'm actually pretty darn speechless about this place.  It was quite the adventure trying to locate but gosh darn it, WE FOUND IT!  It definitely owns up to being considered a "Hidden Gem" in Birmingham. I've been hearing about this place for quite awhile and I am elated that I finally got to try it with two of my friends from work!
  Coming from someone who tends to not lean towards sandwiches, this place made me a believer!  These sandwiches are absolutely  handcrafted to perfection!  Specifically, the smoked turkey on whole wheat with lettuce, tomato, spicy mustard, pepper jack cheese, oil and vinegar, black olives and salt & pepper was delicious!  So many toppings and meat made this an excellent lunch PLUS chips and a pickle all in a basket for $8.25.  Cash Only.  You have been warned but they have an ATM on site.  
  Indoor, bar seating is available.  We opted to sit in the courtyard area and it was such a pretty day!  You will be surrounded by garage type decor/ treasure.  Much to look at but it doesn't interfere with enjoying the atmosphere and the food!
  If you've heard about this place and you are reading this review, you MUST try it!

• Jim M.

  star star star star star_border 31 May 2026

  What a neat place, we came here for lunch as it was close to one of our offices. We got there right at 11 when they opened. When we walked in the bartender asked if we had been there before. We replied this is our first. The next words out of his mouth was "we only take cash" ... well I for one never carry cash, so he quickly said well we have an atm in the back. Which this is pretty smart on their side as they do not have to pay the credit/debit card charges the customer does. We ordered at the kitchen area and it is a custom sandwich. I got the smoked turkey hot. It came out about 10 minutes later. I have to admit it was a really good sandwich. They do serve these on top of regular chips.
  All in all this is a good little place for lunch, so if you are in the area this would be a good spot for lunch.

• Jesse R.

  star star star star star 29 May 2026

  These are the best handcrafted sandwiches in the metro area.  Once you get past the cash-only part of the visit you'll be amazed at the awesome meal you're about to receive.  
  
  The ambience is less garage oriented and more like a garage sale.  Junk everywhere that makes the charm of this place that much more.  
  
  BRING CASH WITH YOU.  Other than that, enjoy!

• Kami Lynn W.

  star star star star star 16 May 2026

  I had my first experience at the Garage recently on a late cold Sunday afternoon.
  
  We took two seats at the bar and order some cold beers, whiskey shots, and a couple of sandwiches. I have always heard wonderful things about their sandwiches and boy they did not disappoint.
  
  I customized my own sandwich, wheat bread, roast beef, onion, jalapeño, mustard, mayo, cheese. Oh my, it comes with ruffled potato chips and a pickle. It is a ton of food but it was so good I couldn't stop eating and ate every bite. Delightful!
  You can get your sandwich warm or cold, I prefer cold sandwiches and my husband warm so it's the best place for both of us to get what we want.
  
  After dinner we ventured outside to the beautiful courtyard, chairs and tables everywhere old windows and doors sitting around. Very rustic and a great place to just hang out.
  They also have a bar cat which is right up my ally, super sweet kitty.
  
  One thing to remember is this is a cash bar only, but they do have an ATM in the back.